当前位置 :
为什么数学是思维科学而不是自然科学
1人问答
更新时间:2024-04-19 16:25:33
问题描述:

为什么数学是思维科学而不是自然科学

陈翀回答:
  其实这很明显是依赖于对数学和科学的定义。这个问题之所以有争议,以前是在于数学能否被证伪及数学能否被观察被操作的问题上。这个问题不是否认数学在科学中的重要性,而是对于数学和科学的属性的一个思考而已   贴一下wiki里数学和科学关系那一段吧,有兴趣可以了解一下   Mathematicsasscience   CarlFriedrichGauss,himselfknownasthe"princeofmathematicians",referredtomathematicsas"theQueenoftheSciences".   CarlFriedrichGaussreferredtomathematicsas"theQueenoftheSciences".[21]IntheoriginalLatinReginaScientiarum,aswellasinGermanKöniginderWissenschaften,thewordcorrespondingtosciencemeans(fieldof)knowledge.Indeed,thisisalsotheoriginalmeaninginEnglish,andthereisnodoubtthatmathematicsisinthissenseascience.Thespecializationrestrictingthemeaningtonaturalscienceisoflaterdate.Ifoneconsiderssciencetobestrictlyaboutthephysicalworld,thenmathematics,oratleastpuremathematics,isnotascience.AlbertEinsteinhasstatedthat"asfarasthelawsofmathematicsrefertoreality,theyarenotcertain;andasfarastheyarecertain,theydonotrefertoreality."[6]   Manyphilosophersbelievethatmathematicsisnotexperimentallyfalsifiable,andthusnotascienceaccordingtothedefinitionofKarlPopper.[22]However,inthe1930simportantworkinmathematicallogicshowedthatmathematicscannotbereducedtologic,andKarlPopperconcludedthat"mostmathematicaltheoriesare,likethoseofphysicsandbiology,hypothetico-deductive:puremathematicsthereforeturnsouttobemuchclosertothenaturalscienceswhosehypothesesareconjectures,thanitseemedevenrecently."[23]Otherthinkers,notablyImreLakatos,haveappliedaversionoffalsificationismtomathematicsitself.   Analternativeviewisthatcertainscientificfields(suchastheoreticalphysics)aremathematicswithaxiomsthatareintendedtocorrespondtoreality.Infact,thetheoreticalphysicist,J.M.Ziman,proposedthatscienceispublicknowledgeandthusincludesmathematics.[24]Inanycase,mathematicssharesmuchincommonwithmanyfieldsinthephysicalsciences,notablytheexplorationofthelogicalconsequencesofassumptions.Intuitionandexperimentationalsoplayaroleintheformulationofconjecturesinbothmathematicsandthe(other)sciences.Experimentalmathematicscontinuestogrowinimportancewithinmathematics,andcomputationandsimulationareplayinganincreasingroleinboththesciencesandmathematics,weakeningtheobjectionthatmathematicsdoesnotusethescientificmethod.Inhis2002bookANewKindofScience,StephenWolframarguesthatcomputationalmathematicsdeservestobeexploredempiricallyasascientificfieldinitsownright.   Theopinionsofmathematiciansonthismatterarevaried.Manymathematiciansfeelthattocalltheirareaascienceistodownplaytheimportanceofitsaestheticside,anditshistoryinthetraditionalsevenliberalarts;othersfeelthattoignoreitsconnectiontothesciencesistoturnablindeyetothefactthattheinterfacebetweenmathematicsanditsapplicationsinscienceandengineeringhasdrivenmuchdevelopmentinmathematics.Onewaythisdifferenceofviewpointplaysoutisinthephilosophicaldebateastowhethermathematicsiscreated(asinart)ordiscovered(asinscience).ItiscommontoseeuniversitiesdividedintosectionsthatincludeadivisionofScienceandMathematics,indicatingthatthefieldsareseenasbeingalliedbutthattheydonotcoinci
最新更新
热门数学
PC端 | 移动端 | mip端
问答网(wenda2.com)汇总了汉语字典,新华字典,成语字典,组词,词语,在线查字典,中文字典,英汉字典,在线字典,康熙字典等等,是学生查询学习资料的好帮手,是老师教学的好助手。
声明:本网站尊重并保护知识产权,根据《信息网络传播权保护条例》,如果我们转载的作品侵犯了您的权利,请在一个月内通知我们,我们会及时删除。

邮箱:联系方式:

Copyright©2009-2021 问答网 wenda2.com 版权所有 闽ICP备2022000227号-1